1930 – 1940 – 1950 – 1960 – 1970 – 1980 – 1990 – 2000 – 2010 – Coaches
| Tori Bagan | Homestead | Inducted 2023 | 2008 – 11 |
| Kevin Behrens | Munster | Inducted 2023 | 2008 – 11 |
| Kait Flederbach | Westfield | Inducted 2023 | 2007 – 10 |
| Tyler Fozkos | Chesterton | Inducted 2023 | 2008 – 11 |
| Olivia Kabacinski | Chesterton | Inducted 2023 | 2009 – 12 |
| Lacey Locke | Carmel | Inducted 2023 | 2010 – 13 |
| Zoe Mattingly | Zionsville | Inducted 2023 | 2009 – 12 |