1930 – 1940 – 1950 – 1960 – 1970 – 1980 – 1990 – 2000 – 2010 – Coaches
| Richard “Dick” Braman | Gary Mann | Inducted 2023 | 1951 – 52 |
| James Etter | Hammond | Inducted 2007 | 1948 – 52 |
| Dennis Floden | South Bend Riley | Inducted 2007 | 1954 – 58 |
| Thomas Gustafson | South Bend Central | Inducted 2023 | 1954 – 55 |
| Leslie Lobaugh | South Bend Central | Inducted 2007 | 1950 – 54 |
| James Murphy | Hammond | Inducted 2007 | 1953 – 55 |
| John Odusch | South Bend Riley | Inducted 2007 | 1954 – 58 |
| Pat “Corky” Rhodes | Gary Mann | Inducted 2007 | 1950 – 54 |
| John Roethke | Columbus | Inducted 2007 | 1955 – 59 |
| John Vogel | Columbus | Inducted 2019 | 1956 – 58 |
| John Walker | Muncie Burris | Inducted 2023 | 1958 – 59 |
| Maurice Woodworth | Lafayette Jeff | Inducted 2015 | 1952 – 55 |