Columbus High School, 1962 – 66
Joe Sheehy swam for Columbus High School, and was undefeated in the 100-yard butterfly event for four straight years, from 1962-63 until 1965-66. He was the first man to accomplish this feat in IHSAA swimming history. During this time, he also was a part of the three-time state championship 200 Medley Relay team from Columbus, in the years of 1963-64, 1964-65, 1965-66.